Story of the Day: Bill Moyers' Masterful Speech on Media Reform

They have even managed to turn the escalation of a failed war into a "surge," as if it were a current of electricity through a wire, instead of blood spurting from the ruptured vein of a soldier. - Bill Moyers

Though the brilliant and tireless Bill Moyers made this speech last week at the third National Conference on Media Reform, I would feel remiss not to share it with you. For many of the Bush years, Moyers was the only voice on television speaking truth to power - before Olbermann and Cafferty were given time. For those of you who are familiar with his work, you'll also be heartened to know that he's returning to PBS with a new show covering the media. And for those of you who aren't, well, you're in for a treat.

Simply put, Bill Moyers is an impressive human being. I'll restrain myself right now from writing paragraphs on Moyers because I'd rather you read and/or listen to his words. Here are just some excerpts to whet your appetite (though I urge you not to miss one single word of this speech):

BILL MOYERS: BENJAMIN FRANKLIN ONCE SAID, "Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for dinner."

"Liberty," he said, "is a well-armed lamb, contesting the vote."

My fellow lambs -- it's good to be in Memphis and find you well-armed with passion for democracy, readiness for action, and courage for the next round in the fight for a free and independent press in America. I salute the conviction that brought you here. I cherish the spirit that fills this hall, and the camaraderie that we share here.

All too often, the greatest obstacle to reform is the reform movement itself. Factions rise, fences are erected, jealousies mount, and the cause all of us believe in is lost in the shattered fragments of what once was a clear and compelling vision.

Reformers, in fact, often remind me of Baptists. I speak as a Baptist. I know whereof I speak. One of my favorite stories is of the fellow who was about to jump off a bridge, when another fellow ran up to him crying, "Stop, stop, don't do it."

The man on the bridge looks down and asks, "Why not?"

"Well, there's much to live for."

"What for?"

"Well, your faith. Your religion."

"Yes?"

"Are you religious?"

"Yes."

"Me, too. Christian or Buddhist?"

"Christian."

"Me, too. Are you Catholic or Protestant?"

"Protestant."

"Me, too. Methodist, Baptist or Presbyterian?"

"Baptist."

"Me, too. Are you Baptist Church of God or Baptist Church of the Savior?"

"Baptist Church of God."

"Me, too. Are you Original Baptist Church of God or Reformed Baptist Church of God?"

"Reformed Baptist Church of God."

"Me, too. Are you Reformed Baptist Church of God Reformation of 1879, or Reform Baptist Church of God Reformation of 1917?"

"1917."

Whereupon, the second fellow turned red in the face and yelled, "Die, you heretic scum," and pushed him off the bridge.

DOESN'T THAT SOUND LIKE A REFORM MOVEMENT? But by avoiding contentious factionalism, you have created a strong movement. And I will confess to you that I was skeptical when Bob McChesney and John Nichols first raised with me the issue of media consolidation a few years ago. I was sympathetic but skeptical. The challenge of actually doing something about this issue beyond simply bemoaning its impact on democracy was daunting. How could we hope to come up with an effective response to any measurable force? It seemed inexorable, because all over the previous decades, a series of mega-media mergers have swept the country, each deal bigger than the last. The lobby representing the broadcast, cable, and newspapers industries was extremely powerful, with an iron grip on lawmakers and regulators alike.

...

For years, the media marketplace for opinions about public policy has been dominated by a highly disciplined, thoroughly networked, ideological "noise machine," to use David Brock’s term. Permeated with slogans concocted by big corporations, their lobbyists, and their think tank subsidiaries, public discourse has effectively changed the meaning of American values. Day after day, the ideals of fairness and liberty and mutual responsibility have been stripped of their essential dignity and meaning in people's lives. Day after day, the egalitarian creed of our Declaration of Independence is trampled underfoot by hired experts and sloganeers, who speak of the "death tax," "the ownership society," "the culture of life," "the liberal assault on God and family," "compassionate conservatism," "weak on terrorism," "the end of history," "the clash of civilizations," "no child left behind." They have even managed to turn the escalation of a failed war into a "surge," as if it were a current of electricity through a wire, instead of blood spurting from the ruptured vein of a soldier.

The Orwellian filigree of a public sphere in which language conceals reality, and the pursuit of personal gain and partisan power, is wrapped in rhetoric that turns truth to lies and lies to truth. So it is that limited government has little to do with the Constitution or local economy anymore. Now it means corporate domination and the shifting of risk from government and business to struggling families and workers. Family values now mean imposing a sectarian definition of the family on everyone else. Religious freedom now means majoritarianism and public benefits for organized religion without any public burdens. And patriotism has come to mean blind support for failed leaders.

It's what happens when an interlocking media system filters through commercial values or ideology, the information and moral viewpoints people consume in their daily lives. And by no stretch of the imagination can we say today that the dominant institutions of our media are guardians of democracy.

...

Likewise, people have to see how money and politics actually work and concretely grasp the consequences for their pocketbooks and their lives before they will act. But while media organizations supply a lot of news and commentary, they tell us almost nothing about who really wags the system and how. When I watch one of those faux debates on a Washington public affairs show, with one politician saying, "This is a bad bill," and the other politician saying, "This is a good bill," I yearn to see the smiling, nodding, Beltway anchor suddenly interrupt and insist, "Good bill or bad bill, this is a bought bill. Now, let's cut to the chase. Whose financial interests are you advancing with this bill?"

Then there's the social cost of free trade. For over a decade, free trade has hovered over the political system like a biblical commandment striking down anything -- trade unions, the environment, indigenous rights, even the constitutional standing of our own laws passed by our elected representatives -- that gets in the way of unbridled greed. The broader negative consequences of this agenda, increasingly well-documented by scholars, get virtually no attention in the dominant media. Instead of reality, we get optimistic, multicultural scenarios of coordinated global growth. And instead of substantive debate, we get a stark formulated choice between free trade to help the world and gloomy-sounding protectionism that will set everyone back.

The degree to which this has become a purely ideological debate, devoid of any factual basis that people can weigh the gains and losses is reflected in Thomas Friedman's astonishing claim, stated not long ago in a television interview, that he endorsed the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA) without even reading it. That is simply because it stood for "free trade." We have reached the stage when the Poo-Bahs of punditry have only to declare that "the world is flat," for everyone to agree it is, without going to the edge and looking over themselves.

I think what's happened is not indifference or laziness or incompetence, but the fact that most journalists on the plantation have so internalized conventional wisdom that they simply accept that the system is working as it should. I'm doing a documentary this spring called "Buying the War," and I can't tell you again how many reporters have told me that it just never occurred to them that high officials would manipulate intelligence in order to go to war. Hello?

Similarly, the question of whether or not our economic system is truly just is off the table for investigation and discussion, so that alternative ideas, alternative critiques, alternative visions never get a hearing. And these are but a few of the realities that are obscured. What about this growing inequality? What about the re-segregation of our public schools? What about the devastating onward march of environmental deregulation? All of these are examples of what happens when independent sources of knowledge and analysis are so few and far between on the plantation.

So if we need to know what is happening, and Big Media won't tell us; if we need to know why it matters, and Big Media won't tell us; if we need to know what to do about it, and Big Media won't tell us, it's clear what we have to do. We have to tell the story ourselves.

And this is what the plantation owners feared most of all. Over all those decades here in the South, when they used human beings as chattel, and quoted scripture to justify it, property rights over human rights was God's way, they secretly lived in fear that one day -- instead of saying, "Yes, Massa" -- those gaunt, weary, sweat-soaked field hands, bending low over the cotton under the burning sun, would suddenly stand up straight, look around, see their sweltering and stooping kin and say, "This ain't the product of intelligent design. The boss man in the big house has been lying to me. Something is wrong with this system."

This is the moment freedom begins, the moment you realize someone else has been writing your story, and it's time you took the pen from his hand and started writing it yourself.

...

And in case you do get lonely, I'll leave you with this. As my plane was circling Memphis the other day, I looked out across those vast miles of fertile soil that once were plantations, watered by the Mississippi River, and the sweat from the brow of countless men and women who had been forced to live somebody else's story. I thought about how in time, with a lot of martyrs, they rose up, one here, then two, then many, forging a great movement that awakened America's conscience and brought us closer to the elusive but beautiful promise of the Declaration of Independence. As we made our last approach, the words of a Marge Piercy poem began to form in my head, and I remembered all over again why I was coming and why you were here:

What can they do
to you? Whatever they want.
They can set you up, they can
bust you, they can break
your fingers, they can
burn your brain with electricity,
blur you with drugs till you
can t walk, can’t remember, they can
take your child, wall up
your lover. They can do anything
you can’t blame them
from doing. How can you stop
them? Alone, you can fight,
you can refuse, you can
take what revenge you can
but they roll over you.

But two people fighting
back to back can cut through
a mob, a snake-dancing file
can break a cordon, an army
can meet an army.

Two people can keep each other
sane, can give support, conviction,
love, massage, hope, sex.
Three people are a delegation,
a committee, a wedge. With four
you can play bridge and start
an organization. With six
you can rent a whole house,
eat pie for dinner with no
seconds, and hold a fundraising party.
A dozen make a demonstration.
A hundred fill a hall.
A thousand have solidarity and your own newsletter;
ten thousand, power and your own paper;
a hundred thousand, your own media;
ten million, your own country.

It goes on one at a time,
it starts when you care
to act, it starts when you do
it again after they said no,
it starts when you say We
and know who you mean, and each
day you mean one more.

Bill Moyers at the National Conference for Media Reform
Amy Goodman's Democracy Now

Audio of speech
Truthout

Comments

[MediaBloodhound]

Bill Moyers' Masterful Speech on Media Reform

[Corinne Bowers]

The Bush Plan: Give War a Chance

Brings to mind a John Lennon song gone terribly wrong......

Song: GIVE WAR A CHANCE LYRICS

Ev'rybody's talking about
Bagism, Shagism, Dragism, Madism, Ragism, Tagism
This-ism, that-ism
Isn't it the most
All we are saying is give war a chance
All we are saying is give war a chance

Ev'rybody's talking about
Muslims, Shi'ites, God-willing, "for Allah" killing,
Suicide bombings, and throngings to beheadings,
And bye bye, bye byes.
All we are saying is give war a chance
All we are saying is give war a chance

Let me tell you now
Ev'rybody's talking about
Revolution, Evolution, Mastication, Flagelolation, Regulations.
Integrations, Meditations, United Nations, Congratulations
All we are saying is give war a chance
All we are saying is give war a chance

Oh Let's stick to it
Ev'rybody's talking about
bin Laden, George Bush, Donald Rumsfeld, Saddam Hussein,
Hilary Clinton, Dick Cheney, Barack Obama, Nancy Pelosi, Right Wingers,
Tree Huggers
All we are saying is give war a chance
All we are saying is give war a chance

[Louis Vuitton Outlet]

Nike Air Jordan can be a Gucci outlet renowned manufacturer label engrossed in fabricating fashionable Gucci outlet online couple for offspring, older individuals, men, and ladies. Gucci sale.

Nike Air Jordan is frequently popular as Jordan Concords during the small configuration and is also pretty admired Jordan 11 Concord and acknowledged due to products created of chic sports Jordan Retro 11 Concord activities boots who have rake in globally acknowledgement Jordan Retro 10 for being very resilient and cozy. Jordan 10 The label on the money gathering is supported about the label of Jordan 10 Chicago its holder Michael Jordan who was an amateur of latest Louis Vuitton Outlet solution footwear; he employed to get well-known Cheap Louis Vuitton Sale as being a faultless icon in the most recent strategy marketplace.

He commenced up New Orleans Saints Jerseys in 1985, the monetary gathering was commenced with Youth Saints Jersey some staff that everlasting fetched new creations Women's Saints Jersey for the business. But using the means of time Custom Saints Jersey boots received globally credits Custom NFL Jerseys and a great number of paying out clientele Customized NFL Jerseys who ended up most up-to-date tactic savvy Personalized NFL Jerseys population and preferred to put on boots of surplus well worth and content.

Now, using under consideration the Christian Louboutin Sale qualifications the fiscal gathering has, I Christian Louboutin Shoes ought declare that Nike Air Jordan has become toiling while in the wares of flexible Louboutin Shoes specifics which might be getting designed for people getting Louboutin Sale.

Assorted purely natural world about vogue Cheap Jordans and hope to produce a group on their couple of boot properly by Jordan 11 shopping into latest fashion. Nike Air Jordan 's boots are obtainable Jordan Retro 11 in divergent range- they offer a large kind of boots in divergent hues,Jordan XI creations, profile, and of course in divergent selling price. The cost construction of the boots differs from one method of Jordan 11 Concord a further; this really is fully approximately your possibility and likings.

When your allocation Cheap True Religion Jeans sanctions you to depart for remarkably charge boots with the True Religion Jeans then you definately should depart for it, since the finest,True Religion Cheap the standard.Any person who professes True Religion Outlet to love basketball just isn't a real follower of your game if he will not know the exploits of the best athlete who actually performed the game.

Just after all, you can find conceivably no Uggs On Sale basketball admirer who doesn't know the fame and exploits Ugg On Sale of Michael Jordan.

Even individuals that have been born Uggs following his retirement continue to be attentive to the echoes of the Jordan Uggs Outlet period as manifested from the acceptance of Uggs Boots quantity 23 in basketball jerseys, inside Uggs On Sale the variety of vain tries to emulate gliding from the Cheap Jordans air for a dunk that only His Airness can execute, and of Jordan 7 course, from the enormous recognition of Jordan sneakers hoping Jordan Retro 7 that some regular kid from an not known corner of the world Jordan 13 will someday have the game during the method that Michael Louis Vuitton Jordan did.

Michael Jordan's fame pass on not Louis Vuitton Outlet merely in the basketball courts he performed on, New Nike Air Jordans Shoes from his School days at Cheap Jordans North Carolina as many as his time for the NBA together with the Abercrombie And fitch Outlet and also the Abercrombie And fitch Online Washington Wizards, even at Spain for the 1992 Cheap Abercrombie And fitch Barcelona Olympics.

In each one of these locations and time, nike free run acquired repute for staying a fearless executioner with the most nike frees tricky photographs that has a penchant for taking the sport cheap nike free profitable shot once the game is about the line, and in Cheap NFL Jerseys inspiring his teammates to excel to NFL Jerseys greater heights. This only triggered men and women to Cheap Jerseys flock to watch him play, widening his
Nike Dunks base of supporters. For that reason, what's more, it enlarged the repute of Jordan sneakers, which has Nike Air Maxturn into carefully determined using the gentleman. As Air Max Shoesa result, Air Jordans happen to be worn all over Cheap Supras the place, with most hoping to at the very least Supras Shoes
emulate a number of his remarkable difficult court moves.